State Medicaid programs are federally mandated to cover applied behavior analysis (ABA) services for children diagnosed with autism. ABA is a crucial therapeutic service that helps children with autism develop important life skills, improve their social behaviors, and enhance their overall quality of life. Given its significance, ABA is often considered a cornerstone of autism treatment. However, a recent Indiana Medicaid ABA audit by the Office of Inspector General (OIG) for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has uncovered substantial issues with Indiana’s Medicaid payments for ABA services, potentially compromising the care these children are receiving.
Indiana’s Medicaid Payments: A Snapshot of the Problem
In 2020, the state of Indiana made a staggering $101.8 million in Medicaid payments for ABA services, marking the second highest total in the U.S. for that year. This large sum reflects the demand for these essential services within the state and the importance of Medicaid in funding autism care. However, an audit conducted by the OIG has revealed troubling discrepancies and potential violations in how these funds were managed.
The audit uncovered that approximately $56 million in ABA payments made by Indiana Medicaid were improper, with $39.4 million of those funds being billed to the Federal Medicaid program. Furthermore, an additional $76.7 million in “potentially improper” payments was identified, $53.2 million of which was the responsibility of the Federal government. These findings signal a significant breakdown in the oversight of Medicaid’s fee-for-service payments for ABA services, raising red flags about the effectiveness of Indiana’s management of these crucial resources. The Indiana Medicaid ABA audit has exposed critical gaps that need to be addressed for the sake of vulnerable children.
An Audit of Indiana’s ABA Payments
The Indiana Medicaid ABA audit focused on Medicaid’s fee-for-service payments from January 2019 to December 2020, which totaled $151.1 million, with $104.5 million of that amount covered by the federal government. To assess the legitimacy of these payments, the OIG conducted a random sample audit of 100 enrollee-months, which included invoices from 41 unique ABA facilities and 96 unique enrollees. The results of this sample audit were troubling.
For 97 out of the 100 sampled enrollee-months, Indiana Medicaid had paid $433,472 for at least one claim line that failed to comply with either state or federal Medicaid guidelines. In other words, nearly 97% of the claims examined did not meet the required documentation standards, which raises serious concerns about the integrity of the payment system. These deficiencies reveal significant gaps in Indiana’s ability to monitor and regulate ABA services under Medicaid, potentially compromising the treatment provided to children with autism.
What Went Wrong?
The Indiana Medicaid ABA audit uncovered several key issues that contributed to the improper and potentially improper payments. One of the most significant issues was inadequate documentation. The OIG found that many of the session notes submitted by ABA providers failed to meet the required standards for proper documentation. These deficiencies included incomplete or missing details about the services provided, making it difficult to assess whether the services were actually delivered as described.
In addition to documentation issues, the audit found that some services were provided by staff members who did not have the appropriate credentials. In other cases, ABA services were rendered to children who had not undergone the necessary diagnostic evaluations or received the required treatment referrals. These lapses in adherence to Medicaid’s guidelines undermine the efficacy of the care being delivered and jeopardize the quality of services for children with autism.
Perhaps most concerning was the discovery of “potentially improper” ABA payments amounting to $76.7 million. The issues related to these payments included session notes that failed to fully disclose the extent of the services provided, as well as claims that included time spent on meals, breaks, naps, and other non-therapy activities that do not count as allowable ABA activities under Medicaid rules. Furthermore, some session notes included activities related to recreation or academics, which are not considered part of the ABA curriculum, raising further doubts about the appropriateness of the billed services.
The Impact on Children with Autism and Their Families
The findings of the Indiana Medicaid ABA audit have far-reaching implications. Medicaid is the primary funding source for many families seeking ABA services for their children with autism, and the improper handling of these funds can have a direct impact on the care children receive. Without proper oversight, there is a risk that children may not receive the level of therapy they need to make meaningful progress. The OIG report clearly states that these issues could have had a significant effect on the quality of care provided to children with autism in Indiana.
Families relying on Medicaid to access ABA services may find themselves in a difficult situation if these discrepancies continue unchecked. If Medicaid payments are not being properly managed or are being paid out for services that do not meet the required standards, the availability and quality of care may be compromised. This could lead to delays in receiving therapy, inadequate treatment plans, and ultimately, a less effective therapeutic experience for children who rely on these services to thrive.
Recommendations and Next Steps
In response to the audit findings, the OIG made several recommendations for Indiana’s Medicaid program. First, it recommended that Indiana refund $39.4 million to the federal government to address the improper payments identified during the Indiana Medicaid ABA audit. The OIG also urged the state to provide more specific guidance to ABA providers regarding proper documentation standards. This would help ensure that future claims meet the necessary criteria for reimbursement and that services are properly accounted for.
Furthermore, the OIG recommended that Indiana Medicaid perform periodic post-payment reviews of ABA services to identify potential discrepancies or improper payments. Regular oversight could help prevent future issues and ensure that Medicaid dollars are being spent appropriately. By taking these steps, Indiana could improve the accuracy of its Medicaid payments and provide better oversight to ensure that children with autism receive the care they need.
A Call for Stronger Oversight Across States
Indiana’s case highlights the critical need for robust oversight in Medicaid’s administration of ABA services. As more states are responsible for managing Medicaid programs that cover ABA therapy, the Indiana Medicaid ABA audit serves as an important reminder of the challenges and risks associated with overseeing these services. It is crucial that all states take the necessary steps to ensure that Medicaid funds are used appropriately and that children with autism continue to receive high-quality care.
While the audit’s findings are concerning, they present an opportunity for Indiana to improve its Medicaid oversight and protect the children who rely on these services. By implementing the OIG’s recommendations, Indiana can work toward ensuring that children with autism receive the care they deserve, while also safeguarding the integrity of the Medicaid program. For families navigating autism care, it is essential that Medicaid programs are effective, transparent, and accountable to ensure that every child has access to the best possible therapeutic services.
 for the U.S. Department of Health and Human..){kind=link}